Why Vader & Obi-Wan Should not Have a Last Confrontation

Why Vader & Obi-Wan Should not Have a Last Confrontation

As Disney+’s newest Star Wars collection nears its finale, followers are ready with bated breath for the climax. From the beginning, many puzzled if the present’s title character would go up towards his former pupil Anakin Skywalker-turned-Darth Vader. However the nearer the collection will get to the climax of the storyline, the extra it feels prefer it wasn’t meant to be.

Obi-Wan Kenobi did not draw back from motion scenes or entertaining lightsaber duels; The struggle between Darth Vader and the third sister within the newest episode is only one instance. And within the finale, there might very effectively be a lightsaber struggle that might function a climax, maybe between Obi-Wan and the brand new Grand Inquisitor (or the Third Sister, ought to she survive). However for Obi-Wan and Vader to go head-to-head within the collection finale would undermine not solely Obi-Wan’s character journey, but in addition the emotional rigidity of the unique trilogy.


RELATED: Star Wars: The Mightiest Sith Lords From Lore

Certainly, a part of Obi-Wan Kenobi’s core story revolves round Obi-Wan confronting his previous errors – together with his personal failure to maintain Anakin from falling to the darkish facet. Nevertheless, his journey is not a lot about confronting his demons as it’s about forgiving himself and shifting ahead.

At first of the collection, Obi-Wan has left the Jedi path. Plagued by his previous, haunted by his guilt for Anakin’s destiny, he now not believes he’s worthy of calling himself a Jedi. However when younger Lukentür Skywalker meets previous Ben Kenobi in A New Hope, the latter is a pleasant previous hermit effectively versed within the Jedi methods and keen to move these classes on to Lukentür. He could remorse it, however he isn’t the tormented man from the miniseries anymore.

To turn out to be the sensible mentor Lukentür meets on Tatooine, Obi-Wan should discover peace with himself, let go of his guilt, and settle for his function as a Jedi. Pulling down Vader most likely would not give Obi-Wan that peace; quite, it could solely circulate into that debt. Such a scene would additionally reinforce the concept the present’s central battle is between Obi-Wan and Vader, whereas the bigger struggle is de facto between Obi-Wan and himself.

When Obi-Wan and Vader meet within the authentic Star Wars movie, it is a highly effective second. The 2 lastly face one another once more after so a few years. For this second in A New Hope, Obi-Wan should finish Kenobi with out absolutely resolving the battle between Obi-Wan and his former pupil in an effort to preserve his emotional rigidity.

In Obi-Wan Kenobi, an epic lightsaber duel between the 2 might finish in solely two methods. If Vader had been to defeat his former grasp, his iconic quote within the authentic movie would not make sense: “After I left you, I used to be simply the learner. Now I am the grasp.” However, if Obi-Wan had been to punch Vader down or pressure him to flee, it could really feel too last. It will massively undermine Vader’s credibility as a galaxy-wide risk going into the unique movie trilogy, and it could give Obi-Wan an excessive amount of closure earlier than their last encounter in A New Hope.

By escaping the clutches of the Empire with the Insurgent faction within the fifth installment of the collection, Obi-Wan Vader has proven he can nonetheless outsmart him. Though Obi-Wan got here out worse from their struggle earlier within the collection, he has confirmed to be the wiser of the 2; till now he’s nonetheless the grasp. That should not change between the tip of the miniseries and A New Hope. Portraying one other direct confrontation between the 2 would shift that steadiness, whatever the final result.

At its core, Obi-Wan Kenobi’s story is about his hero’s return to the best way of the Jedi. Within the fifth episode’s flashback scenes, he tells Anakin that “the purpose of a Jedi is to defend life, not take it”. This might foreshadow how Obi-Wan will discover his Jedi approach once more. Most clearly, he’ll deliver Leia again to her household and shield Lukentür from the Empire’s threats – however perhaps there’s extra to the story.

Reva, the third sister, seems to have survived her encounter with Vader – and seems to be plotting one thing with Lukentür Skywalker on Tatooine. It would not be stunning to see her and Obi-Wan face off once more; She’s clearly not a fan of his, regardless of her newly revealed hatred for Vader. Nevertheless, in such a confrontation, Obi-Wan should not knock Reva down both. As a substitute, it could be an extremely highly effective second to see him assist Reva launch her anger and perhaps even flip to the sunshine. By doing so, Obi-Wan would obtain what he had failed to realize with Anakin and supply closure for his previous errors.

Alternatively, there might not be a last confrontation. Any given chapter within the Star Wars saga, be it a miniseries or a movie trilogy, tends to finish with the defeat of evil and the hero’s triumphant return. Nevertheless, Obi-Wan Kenobi is about in the course of the Empire’s rise to energy – which does not decelerate between the tip of the present and the beginning of the unique trilogy. Of all of the Star Wars traits, it makes essentially the most sense for Obi-Wan Kenobi to finish on an ominous word. Maybe, whereas Obi-Wan has protected the Skywalker twins, he realizes that the true battle is but to come back and he should return to his Jedi roots to arrange for it.

No matter how the collection ends, the battle on the coronary heart of Obi-Wan Kenobi is that of a person struggling to seek out himself after shedding all the pieces. To actually really feel performed, audiences actually need to see the title character develop into the beloved character first dropped at life by Alec Guinness and put together to coach an keen younger man on Tatooine. The confrontation with Vader will happen later. First, Obi-Wan should forgive his previous errors and belief in changing into a Jedi once more.

MORE: Obi-Wan Kenobi: Does Younger Leia Present Pressure Sensitivity?